Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint Live-Action Sparks Controversy Over Bihyung Redesign and Plot Changes

Anticipation for the Omniscient Reader’s Viewpoint live-action adaptation is being overshadowed by mounting criticism. While Omniscient Reader: The Prophet is set to hit theaters in July 2025, its newly released trailer has only intensified the concerns of long-time fans. The biggest issue? A drastic redesign of fan-favorite dokkaebi, Bihyung, that many claim strips away the original’s dark charm.

The film, distributed by Lotte Entertainment and produced by Munpia, has already sparked debate for its creative liberties. Now, with this latest teaser, viewers are more apprehensive than ever.

Bihyung’s New Look Misses the Mark

Bihyung, originally a white-furred dokkaebi with yellow horns and a black robe, acts as the moderator for protagonist Kim Dokja’s “channel” in the manhwa. However, in the trailer, he appears as a pink-faced hologram-like figure with blush tones and cape-like garments. Fans were quick to mock the redesign, likening it to Doraemon and calling it too cartoonish for the story’s intense tone.

Beyond looks, the trailer’s stiff animation and superficial presentation of Bihyung failed to capture the eerie authority the dokkaebi is known for. Despite being one of the first major characters introduced, his treatment here has led many to doubt the adaptation’s faithfulness.

Casting, Plot, and Tone Departures Worry Fans

The backlash doesn’t end with Bihyung. Casting decisions have also sparked heated discussions. BLACKPINK’s Jisoo, cast as teen swordswoman Lee Ji-hye, is in her 30s—prompting confusion among fans. Her use of firearms in the trailer, instead of a sword as in the manhwa, raised further alarms.

Likewise, Ahn Hyo Seop as Kim Dokja appears uncharacteristically timid, pleading with Lee Min Ho’s Yoo Jonghyuk. This is a stark contrast to the calm and calculating protagonist in the original. Even young Lee Gilyoung’s portrayal veers into comedic territory, a mismatch with his mature demeanor in the source.

Further changes, like renaming the first scenario from “Proof of Value” to “Kill or Be Killed,” suggest the live-action might be streamlining or even removing central plot elements—particularly the concept of constellations.

With a whopping 30 billion won budget, Omniscient Reader: The Prophet is one of South Korea’s most ambitious films. But despite its high production value, fans are questioning if it will truly honor the original. To experience the full depth of the story, fans are encouraged to read the Webtoon adaptation or go into the original light novel.

Trending Products

.