A Confusing High School Fantasy That Leaves You Wondering

Peas and Carrots begins like a fairly conventional teenage coming-of-age story centered on Joey Wethersby, a sixteen-year-old New Yorker whose parents were part of a 1990s one-hit-wonder band. Joey persuades her parents to regroup into a new band, sparking her journey towards artistic and personal discovery.

But this seemingly straightforward plot quickly twists into an often baffling high school fantasy that struggles to find its footing.

The film shifts between Joey’s real-world family dynamics and surreal, alternate-dimension scenes where dialogue is limited to the repetitive phrase “peas and carrots,” an odd choice that neither clarifies nor enhances the story.

This linguistic constraint generates moments of odd humor but mostly results in stilted and awkward exchanges that hinder audience connection.

Critics and viewers alike note how the film’s premise, while inventive, leads to a confusing narrative. The balance between typical teen drama elements and the bizarre fantasy sequences feels uneven, with the story struggling to maintain momentum.

Also read: J.J. Abrams’ Star Trek Movies Rewrote How the Franchise Works on TV

Some praise goes to lead actress Kirrilee Berger, whose portrayal of Joey carries authenticity and relatable teenage energy. She effectively expresses the frustration and confusion her character experiences, making her performance a standout amid the film’s awkwardness.

Unfortunately, her charm alone cannot fully compensate for the script’s patchy execution and the film’s inability to smoothly integrate its imaginative concept with effective storytelling.​

Surreal Storytelling Meets Unfulfilled Potential

The film attempts to be more than just a teen drama by embedding surreal, dreamlike sequences where Joey is transported nightly to an alternate reality. This world is inhabited by characters who communicate almost exclusively using three fixed words: “peas,” “and,” and “carrots.”

The idea seems to symbolize communication barriers and deeper emotional disconnects within Joey’s family and herself. Yet, the execution leaves audiences puzzled rather than enlightened. These segments often feel disconnected and stilted, breaking the narrative flow instead of complementing the real-world story.

Some viewers might appreciate the film as a kind of experimental family musical comedy blending existential themes with light humor and music. The soundtrack and musical performances, including contributions from notable figures like Marky Ramone, attempt to add vibrancy and cultural texture to the film.

But ultimately, the surreal elements create confusion, disrupting any emotional engagement. The script’s refusal to explain or contextualize the fantasy dimension leaves many questions unanswered, frustrating viewers hoping for clearer thematic insight or character development.

The comedy, described as subtle and dry by some, offers occasional relief but is overshadowed by the film’s awkward pacing and dialogue. Meanwhile, the family’s interpersonal tension and Joey’s journey toward self-expression get little room to grow beneath the script’s quirks.

The film’s ambition to mix multi-generational entertainment with a strange logic may intrigue niche audience members, yet for most, it feels like the story never reaches a satisfying resolution or meaningful emotional payoff.​

What This Means for Viewers and the Film’s Future

Peas and Carrots leaves audiences with mixed feelings. While it contains elements that showcase potential, such as Kirrilee Berger’s engaging lead performance and a few clever musical moments, the experience is muddled by a confusing story and dialogue that often feels forced or unnatural.

The film’s attempt to blend high school drama with abstract fantasy comes across as disjointed, limiting its appeal to a broader audience.

Its theatrical release was limited, and the film is likely to find most of its viewers through streaming and home video, where more patient audiences might appreciate its offbeat nature without the pressure of the big screen expectations.

Fans of experimental cinema or surrealistic narratives may find some value in the film’s bold approach, but for viewers seeking a coherent, emotionally resonant story, Peas and Carrots is more frustrating than fulfilling.

The film also teases potential future developments with a post-credits scene that some feel should have been expanded to explore romantic or familial storylines more deeply.

This hint at a sequel or continuation leaves open the possibility that the filmmakers might refine the story and tone in upcoming projects. However, whether they can overcome the current film’s narrative shortcomings remains an open question.​

Peas and Carrots is a perplexing film with undeniable ambition but flawed execution. It’s awkward high school fantasy and stilted dialogue create a confusing mix that alienates as often as it intrigues, making it a difficult watch for many but possibly an intriguing curiosity for others who value unique, risky storytelling ventures.​

Also read: Peter Hujar’s Day Reveals Ira Sachs’ Intimate Portrait and One of the Year’s Best Acted Films